Trading and selling cards without tears
Trading is half the fun of collecting, and it is where most of the tears come from. A few house rules stop the lopsided trades, and a few habits keep selling safe.
The short answer
For trading: agree one rule in advance, that any card that is shiny or textured gets looked up before it changes hands, and that trades can be undone the same day. For selling: a local game store is the safe, quick option; selling online pays more and needs tracked postage and a payment method that protects you.
Trading between kids
House rules that work
- Shiny or textured cards get looked up first. Two minutes on a price site, together. How. Plain cards can be traded freely.
- Both kids have to be happy. A fair trade is not always equal value. Swapping a $3 card for a favorite Pokémon worth $1 is fine if both are glad.
- A same-day take-back. Either kid can undo a trade before the end of the day, no questions asked.
- No trading with much older kids without a parent. This is where most lopsided trades happen.
- The best cards stay home. Take a "trade binder" of cards your kid is willing to lose. The special ones do not go to school.
How lopsided trades happen
| What is said | What is going on |
|---|---|
| "I'll give you ten cards for that one." | Ten commons are worth less than a dollar. One shiny card can be worth fifty |
| "This one is super rare." | Maybe. Look it up. Kids repeat things they have heard |
| "It's a gold card, it's worth loads." | Gold metal cards and many "gold" cards from market stalls are not real. How to tell |
| "You have to decide now." | A fair trade is still fair tomorrow |
Many schools ban trading cards, or ban trading them, precisely because of disputes. If cards are allowed, the trade binder rule above saves a lot of grief. If a trade has gone badly wrong, a calm word with the other parent usually sorts it out; the kids rarely meant harm.
Selling cards
First find out what you have: check what the cards are worth. Then pick a route.
| Where | You get | Effort and risk | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Local game store | Around half of the going price, in cash or store credit | Low. In and out in ten minutes | A handful of cards, or when you want it done |
| Online marketplace | Close to the going price, minus fees and postage | Medium. Photos, packing, posting, and the odd dispute | Single cards worth $20 or more |
| Local meet-up (community groups) | Close to the going price, no fees | Higher. You are meeting a stranger | Bigger lots, if you are comfortable with it |
| Bulk by weight or count | A few dollars per thousand cards | Low | Clearing out commons |
Selling online without getting burned
- Photograph the actual card, front and back. Clear, bright, out of the sleeve if you can do it safely. Show any wear honestly.
- Price from sold listings, not asking prices. Look at what the same card in the same condition actually sold for.
- Get paid through the marketplace. Never by a "friends and family" payment, a cheque, gift cards or a payment app with no protection.
- Post it tracked. Card in a sleeve, in a toploader, taped between two pieces of card, in a padded envelope. Keep the receipt.
- For anything over about $100, add a signature on delivery. "It never arrived" is the most common scam against sellers.
Scams aimed at sellers
| The move | What to do |
|---|---|
| The buyer "accidentally" overpays and asks for the difference back | Refund the whole payment through the site and start again. Never send money separately |
| "Can we do this off the site to save fees?" | No. You lose all protection |
| "My courier will collect it" | No. Post it yourself, tracked |
| A message with a link to "confirm your payment" | Do not click. Check inside the site or app itself |
| The buyer claims the card was fake or damaged and returns a different one | Your dated photos of the exact card, front and back, are your evidence |
Meeting someone in person
- Meet in a public place in daylight. Many police stations have a marked safe-exchange spot in the car park. A game store is also good.
- An adult does the deal. Not the kid, however grown-up they feel.
- Cash, counted on the spot.
Buying single cards safely
The same things in reverse. A game store is the simple route. Online, buy from sellers with a long history, check the photos are of the actual card, and be suspicious of any price far below the going rate. See fake cards and resealed packs.
Questions parents ask
Should a kid be selling cards at all?
With a parent, a first sale is a decent lesson in what things are worth. The account, the payment and the posting should all be the adult's.
My kid traded away something valuable. Can we get it back?
Ask the other family the same day, kindly. Most parents will reverse a trade their kid clearly got the better of.
A game store offered much less than the price site shows. Is that a rip-off?
Not usually. A store has to resell the card and carry the risk, so around half is normal. If the gap matters, sell it yourself.