Home / Learn the cards
Learn the cards

Are my kid's cards worth anything?

Most cards are worth a few cents. A few are worth real money, and they are easy to pick out once you know where to look. Here is the two-minute check.

Updated Nov 18, 20266 min read

The short answer

Most are not, a few might be. In a typical shoebox, nine cards in ten are worth under a quarter each. Pull out anything that is shiny, textured, or has a picture covering the whole card, and anything from before about 2003. Look those up by the number printed at the bottom. Everything else is "bulk": great for playing and trading, not for selling.

The two-minute check

  1. Sort out the candidates. Set aside cards that are shiny, have a rough "fingerprint" texture, a picture that fills the whole card, gold edges, or a star (or two or three) at the very bottom.
  2. Read the bottom of the card. You need the card's name and its number, such as 190/164. Where to find them.
  3. Look it up. Type the name and number into a card-price site and read the market price: the average of recent sales. Ignore the highest asking prices; anyone can ask anything.
  4. Be honest about condition. Quoted prices are for "near mint": looks fresh from the pack. Scratches, white edges or bends cut the value by half or more.

Which cards to look at first

Look forWhyTypical value
A picture covering the whole cardThese are the illustration rares that collectors chaseA few dollars to a few hundred
Rough, textured surfaceOnly the top rarities are textured$5 and up
Gold card or gold borderA top rarity in recent sets$5 to $50
Card number higher than the set size (190/164)A "secret" card beyond the normal listOften the best card in the pile
Cards from 1999 to about 2003Old, and many were played to bits, so clean ones are scarceAnything from $1 to thousands for a clean shiny one
A popular PokémonCharizard, Pikachu, Umbreon, Rayquaza, Mewtwo and friends cost more than others of the same rarityOften double

What is almost never worth money

Old does not mean valuable

The headlines are about a handful of 1999 cards in perfect condition. A worn 1999 common is worth about a dollar. If you do find old shiny cards, especially with a small "1st Edition" stamp, put each one in a sleeve before anyone handles it again, and get a second opinion from a game store.

Protecting a good card

The moment a card might be worth more than a few dollars: slide it into a thin penny sleeve, then into a rigid toploader. Both cost pennies. A binder with side-loading pockets is fine for the rest. See what else you need.

Is grading worth it?

Grading means posting a card to a company that scores its condition out of 10 and seals it in a hard case. It costs roughly $15 to $25 a card or more, plus postage, and takes weeks. It only pays for itself on a card already worth around $100 or more in excellent condition. For a kid's collection the honest answer is almost always no.

What to do with the bulk

OptionGood for
Keep it for playingBulk Energy and Trainer cards are exactly what a kid needs to build decks
Trade itYounger kids happily trade commons. See trading without tears
Give it awaySchools, libraries, after-school clubs and younger cousins
Sell it by the boxGame stores buy bulk for a few dollars per thousand cards. Not worth a special trip

Questions parents ask

My kid pulled a card worth $80. Now what?

Sleeve it and put it in a toploader today. Then it is your family's call: keep it, or sell it. How to sell safely.

The price site shows $5 but a listing says $500. Which is right?

The $5. Asking prices mean nothing; look at what cards actually sold for. Wildly high listings are mistakes, jokes or scams.

Are Japanese cards worth more?

Sometimes, to collectors. They are harder to price and cannot be used at events here. Look them up the same way, by name and number.

Should we keep boxes sealed as an investment?

We would not. Some sealed boxes have risen in price; plenty have not, and a kid gets nothing out of a box in a cupboard.